Critical thinkingThe evidence

How does critical thinking matter for jobs?

Critical thinking is one of the ten “essential skills” in the Worker Requirements of O*NET, the US government's primary source of occupational information. The database profiles more than 900 occupations, such as “Registered Nurses”, which between them cover more than 54,000 job titles across the US economy.

Here, we dig into the O*NET data to see how critical thinking matters for jobs.

About a 5-minute read 910 occupations
First, the terms

Importance and Level

For each occupation, O*NET measures importance and level of relevant skills:

Importance

Importance indicates how important a particular skill is to the occupation, ranging from “Not Important” (1) to “Extremely Important” (5).

Level

Level indicates how much of a particular skill the occupation needs, on a 0–7 scale.

Finding 1

Almost every job needs it

Critical thinking matters to 89% of the occupations. By “matters”, we mean it is rated as “important” (3) or more. Only two other essential skills (Active Listening and Speaking) matter to more occupations. See a comparison chart below.

Share of occupations that rate each skill important or more

O*NET's ten essential skills, 910 occupations. Importance 3 (“important”) or higher on the 1–5 scale.

  1. Active Listening
  2. Speaking
  3. Critical Thinking
  4. Monitoring
  5. Reading Comprehension
  6. Writing
  7. Active Learning
  8. Learning Strategies
  9. Mathematics
  10. Science

Try it: Maths is rated important in only 26% of occupations. So does maths matter less than critical thinking?

Finding 2

Importance is not the same as complexity

Importance says whether a job needs critical thinking; level says how much. As you'd expect, these two metrics are highly correlated. In general, the more important critical thinking is to a job, the higher level of it is required too. See the scatterplot below.

Every occupation by how important critical thinking is to it, and how much it needs

Importance on the 1–5 scale, level on the 0–7 scale. Hover a dot to see its occupations.

  • Dot size: number of occupations (1, 10, 46)
  • Trend
  • Named in the text
Hydroelectric planttechnicians Civil engineers

They do measure, however, different aspects of a job's requirements. For example, focus on the coloured vertical line in the graph: it marks the 107 occupations where critical thinking is rated at the same importance (3.88). The level of critical thinking required ranges from 3.12 (Hydroelectric plant technicians) to 4.62 (Civil engineers). In other words, all these occupations lean on critical thinking just as much, but the level of critical thinking required is the highest for civil engineers (tied with bioengineers).

Your turn

Look up a job

Search any of the 910 occupations, by its name or a job title it covers. The names are American and the training described is the US route, so your country may train for the same job differently.

    Registered Nurses

    Considerable preparation: usually a four-year degree.

    Importance of critical thinking
    4.00 / 5 very important
    Level of critical thinking needed
    4.12 / 7 more than 77% of occupations
    • Dot size: number of occupations (1, 10, 46)
    • Trend
    • The job you looked up
    Registered Nurses

    Everything else about this job on O*NET OnLine ↗

    Fine print

    Know the limits

    Before you quote any data here, make sure you have read it right.

    1. It counts occupations, not people. “89% of occupations” isn't “89% of workers”. (Tool 2)
    2. It's American. The job titles and training routes are American. The thinking a job needs is probably similar in other countries, even where pay and training path differ.
    3. The ratings are judgements. Trained analysts rated how much critical thinking each job needs. (Tool 1)
    4. An occupation hides a lot of variety. “Lawyers” covers very different working days. Each rating describes a typical version of the job, not every one.
    5. The ratings have dates. They were made between 2010 and 2026, a different year for different occupations, and 504 of the 910 were made before 2023, before AI chatbots came into everyday use. Jobs change. (Tool 4)